This episode profiles the horrific mass murder of five women in an East Baltimore rowhome in the 3500 block of Elmley Avenue on December 5, 1999. 39-year-old Mary "Lo" McNeil Matthews, Mary's mother, 56-year-old (also named Mary) Mary Helen Collien, Mary's daughter, 18-year-old Makisha Jenkins and two cousins by marriage, 23-year-old Levanna Spearman and 26-year-old Trennell Alston Sommerville were all shot by 27-year-old Ismeal Malik Wilson, 22-year-old Robert Lamont Bryant, 21-year-old Travon McCoy and 19-year-old Tariq Malik. Three hours after the womens' bodies were found, Mary's son, 22-year-old TaVarius McNeal was also found shot to death.
This episode also profiles the unsolved stabbing murder of 22-year-old Diane Lynne Miller, who was found stabbed numerous times, on Route 3 between Route 648 and Dorsey Road in Glen Burnie, on November 24, 1978.